House Rules

Kay Hanifen

She laughed and asked, “Do you want to hurt me?”

“No,” you replied vehemently.

“Then you won’t. You are not the fucked-up thoughts that your brain conjures to torture you.” She said it so simply, as though it was the most obvious thing in the world. The sun was yellow, the sky was blue, and you would never hurt her.

And you believed her.

But you were both wrong.

“I’m alone,” you reply, and she blanches.

“I swear I saw a woman behind you.”

You look over your left shoulder and see her standing in the doorway. Grabbing a wedding photo, you ask, “Is this the woman you saw?”

“Y-yes,” she says, looking as though she’s about to faint.

But now you can talk about what’s really triggering your OCD.

When the song “Walking in a Winter Wonderland” blasts through Alexa, you will no longer be in your home. You will be back on the road with her at your side, laughing and singing along to the song as you wind through the snowy mountain road. She shrieks and you swerve to avoid hitting a deer. The car flips over the guardrails and rolls to the bottom of the hill.

When you wake up, you’re covered in your own blood. Your arm and leg are both bent at the wrong angle, and you’ve been impaled by glass in several places. The final verse of the song is playing. In the span of just three minutes, your life has changed irreversibly. You smell gasoline, and she must too, because her concussion-glazed eyes widen. Thankfully, the car landed on its wheels, so you don’t have to worry about escaping injured and upside down, only injured. The engine ignites, and the flames lick at you as she unbuckles your seatbelt. You manage to get the door open and drag yourself out, but her seatbelt is stuck, and the fire is spreading.

You try to drag yourself to your feet, to help her cut away the seatbelt with a shard of glass, but the moment you put weight on your broken leg, your entire body erupts in agony. You scream and fall to the ground. Something lands beside you. Her phone. Picking up your head, you see her smile weakly one last time before the car erupts into flames. You call 9-1-1 and tell them where you are as you stare at the burning body still inside the car. It isn’t right. You were injured worse. It should have been you that died on that night.

And you know that this is why she haunts you. It’s your fault she died while you got to live.

The song ends and you’re back in your living room. Your face is raw from the tears you shed, and she stands over you looking heartbroken. You thought ghosts were supposed to be cold, but her touch burns like the flames that stole her life away. You hiss and her eyes widen. She pulls back her hand as though she’d been the one burned, and vanishes.

The rest of the anniversary will be quiet, and you won’t see her again for a week.

So, you stop for just a day. You will have a pit in your stomach the whole time and your brain will itch like ants crawling inside your skull, but you do it. And nothing happens. You see her occasionally out of the corner of your eye, but that’s it. After that, you find yourself knocking less and less.

When you remove the black cloth from the final mirror, you find yourself staring at your reflection. There are bags under your eyes so dark that you look as though you’ve been punched. Your hair is lank and greasy and new scars run up and down your body. It’s been more than a year, and you’ve lost weight, but you don’t look healthy. You look sickly and half-dead. You look like a corpse.

Warmth snakes around your waist. You watch in the mirror as she wraps you in her arms and rests her chin on your shoulder. She looks more alive than you do. Her cheeks have color and her eyes sparkle with a familiar humor. You want to turn around, to kiss her and tell her you love her, but she vanishes before you have the chance, leaving only phantom heat in her wake.

Though you’ve grown used to her presence after all this time, the idea will still frighten you. If she isn’t really herself, then it’s an invitation for something darker to take over the house. You’ve seen enough horror movies to know how this works. As soon as you acknowledge the ghosts haunting the house, they escalate into more violence. If you’re particularly unlucky, you might even get possessed.

So, you think on it, and think and think until the weather forecasts a snowstorm. She will not be inside the house, meaning that you can speak more safely. Just in case, you also procure yourself some holy water and you wait for the first flakes to fall.

It’s dark when she finally appears, illuminated by the snow glow like an angel. You will steel your nerves, put on a coat, and go outside to greet her. When she sees you, she gives you the most radiant smile. But she still doesn’t speak.

You ask, “Why are you still here? Do you blame me for what happened?”

She emphatically shakes her head.

“Then why are you here?”

She opens her mouth to speak but no sound comes out, so she points to herself, makes a heart with her fingers, and then points to you. I love you.

A lump will grow in your throat as you reply, “I love you too. Is there a way to help you find peace?”

She takes your hand and, removing your glove, spells out on your palm with burning fingertips, You need to live.

You will be confused. “I am alive.”

Shaking her head, she spells it out again.

Live. She wants you to live more than this haunted half-life. You have been as much a ghost in the past year as she has. Perhaps more of one. You are a soul trapped in a hell of your own making, held prisoner by the pain and the guilt. Tears fall down your cheek, burning hot against the stinging cold of the snow. “You don’t blame me for killing you?”

Again, she shakes her head and reaches up to wipe a tear away with her thumb. The heat of her hand burns against the wind. Never, she mouths, enunciating carefully, Was not your fault. Though the anxious parts of your brain still disagree, you understand now that she was never a danger to you. Her final act was to throw you her phone, which saved your life. It was an insult to her memory not to live to the fullest.

“I love you,” is all you can think to say.

She presses a kiss to your cheek and writes on your palm, Will you live?

You nod, hardly able to speak, and she’s glowing like an angel in the snow as she smiles. “I will live,” you promise.

Her radiance is almost blinding as she vanishes into the night, leaving you alone again in the dark. But this time, when you enter your home, you won’t knock three times. You will text your sister, asking her to come by tomorrow and drive somewhere fun with you. Maybe the movies. It’s been a long time since you’ve last gone to one.

Kay Hanifen was born on a Friday the 13th and once lived for three months in a haunted castle. So, obviously, she had to become a horror writer. Her work has appeared in over forty anthologies and magazines. When she’s not consuming pop culture with the voraciousness of a vampire at a 24-hour blood bank, you can usually find her with her two black cats or at kayhanifenauthor.wordpress.com.

“House Rules” by Kay Hanifen © 2023